ISPAgents vs Splynx vs MikroTik User Manager vs a generic CRM
Compare four approaches to subscriber operations. Start with the workflow you need, then check the evidence, deployment responsibilities, and limits before moving customers.
Prove the path before cutover
Choose the operational fit
ISPAgents: evaluate shipped basic subscriber management and TR-069/CWMP, with guided pilot CRM, billing, payments, and access-policy foundations. Start with a bounded guided pilot, not a full replacement commitment.
Splynx: an ISP suite combining customer management, recurring/prepaid billing, and network management. Consider it when you need a broad ISP workflow; verify your exact package and integrations. Sources: customer management, billing, network management.
MikroTik User Manager: a RouterOS RADIUS package for centralized authentication and authorization, with user profiles, accounting, and documented PayPal profile purchases. Evaluate it for a RouterOS-centered access setup. Source: User Manager documentation.
Generic CRM: a category centered on customer information, interactions, sales, and service relationships. The reference below defines that category, not a universal feature matrix. Check ISP-specific requirements against your chosen product. Source: Salesforce: what is CRM?.
Compare the workflow and the evidence
Shipped below means a capability marked [x] in the ISPAgents readiness checklist. Guided pilot means [~]: qualification and explicit boundaries are required. Not yet shipped means it must not be assumed available.
The comparison is horizontally scrollable on small screens. Competitor links in each cell identify the source for that claim. “Confirm separately” is an evaluation question, not a claim that a competitor lacks the feature. Sources reviewed 16 October 2026.
| Workflow | ISPAgents | Splynx | MikroTik User Manager | Generic CRM |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Customer records | Shipped: basic subscriber records, search, and device assignment. Guided pilot: CRM/Customer 360 foundation. | Customer records, communications, and finance context. Source | Central user database and user profiles. Source | Customer/contact records and interaction history define the category. Source |
| Billing and payment | Guided pilot: invoice, payment, and reconciliation foundations. Full accounting and turnkey live mobile-money clients are not yet shipped. | Recurring/prepaid billing and payment channels. Source | PayPal profile purchases and billing reports are documented; confirm your provider separately. Source | Sales/customer workflows are the category baseline; request proof of your required ISP ledger and provider integration. Category source |
| Access control | Guided pilot: policy previews, approvals, and result recording. General live payment-to-access automation is not yet shipped. Existing FreeRADIUS Status-Server probe and opt-in SQL accounting import are guided pilot. CoA/Disconnect against a real NAS, SQL/API sync, and policy write-back are not qualified. | RADIUS authentication, blocking, and speed limitation. Source | RADIUS authentication/authorization, profile limits, and session accounting. Source | Confirm an AAA adapter and failure policy in the chosen package; the category definition establishes customer workflows only. Category source |
| Router and CPE operations | Shipped: TR-069/CWMP ACS. Guided pilot: config backup/provisioning helpers, SNMP, and MikroTik RouterOS REST client, backup export, neighbor discovery, and enrollment. Guarded RouterOS writes and RouterOS 6 fallback remain product work. | TR-069 ACS, SNMP monitoring, and backups. Source | RADIUS service inside RouterOS; assess device-management requirements separately from this package. Source | Ask for a demonstration of your CPE/AAA integration; it is not established by the category definition. Category source |
| Deployment and ownership | Shipped: multi-tenant platform shell. Guided pilot: onboarding scope agreed per tenant. Managed RADIUS is commercial early access after tenant launch signoff, not public GA or a hard SLA. | Cloud hosting or on-premises options; confirm current terms. Source | Separate RouterOS package, with hardware/architecture and license-dependent limits. Source | Deployment depends on the selected CRM; the category includes cloud delivery. Category source |
Requests to bring to every demo
- Show the same customer, invoice exception, and access-failure case.
- Demonstrate field-job closeout and stock handling if those matter to your team. Splynx documents scheduling and field services; verify the workflow you need. ISPAgents has guided pilot service-order and inventory foundations; a complete technician app, ticketing suite, and customer portal are not yet shipped.
- Ask any AI assistant to show its evidence and permission boundary. ISPAgents device AI summary/audit foundations are guided pilot; a full operator copilot is not yet shipped. No competitor AI capability is inferred here.
- Request an export, an ownership map, and a demonstrated recovery procedure before moving billing or access authority.
Coexist first, review migration later
ISPAgents import preview/apply, external references, and connector records are guided pilot foundations. Live Splynx/UISP adapters are not yet shipped. The pilot offer provides done-for-you import assistance for 50–200 customers, one router/RADIUS endpoint, and one payment/messaging workflow to qualify.
Keep the incumbent as the source of truth, reconcile the sample, and disable write-back until the relevant gates are proven. Rollback is an agreed operator procedure; one-click automated rollback is not yet shipped. Use Splynx migration planning, existing FreeRADIUS scope, and pricing to prepare the review.
Frequently asked questions
Is ISPAgents a complete Splynx replacement today?
No. Basic subscriber records and TR-069/CWMP are shipped. CRM, customer billing, payments, and access-policy foundations are guided pilots. Full accounting and live incumbent adapters are not yet shipped.
Does User Manager include payment features?
Yes. MikroTik documents PayPal profile purchases and billing reports. Check the current RouterOS version, license, and payment requirements for your deployment; do not assume it is only authentication.
Does a generic CRM mean Salesforce specifically?
No. Generic CRM is a category, not one product. Salesforce's CRM explainer is used to define customer/contact and sales workflows. ISP billing, AAA, and field integrations must be checked in the actual product and package you choose.
Can we evaluate ISPAgents alongside an incumbent?
Yes, through a guided pilot using an agreed export, import/reference foundations, and source-of-truth rules. Live Splynx and UISP synchronization is not yet shipped. Start with the 50–200 customer pilot and keep write-back disabled.
Download the ISP migration checklist.
Use it before a vendor comparison call to audit customer data, billing state, access mappings, payment rules, and cutover readiness.
Invoices, balances, statements, credits, refunds, deposits
RADIUS, MikroTik, CPE, connector, approval, rollback
Jobs, photos, GPS, signatures, equipment used
Imports, API sync, validation, reconciliation, cutover
Continue the operations map.
Azotel Alternative
Guided pilot: External references, import preview/apply jobs, connector profiles, and sync-run records are foundations for a guided pilot. Live UISP and Splynx adapters still require implementation.
Open pageCompareNetadmin Alternative
Guided pilot: External references, import preview/apply jobs, connector profiles, and sync-run records are foundations for a guided pilot. Live UISP and Splynx adapters still require implementation.
Open pageSolutionsAutomatic Internet Suspension Software — Guided pilot
Guided pilot: Preview, queued jobs, approvals, result recording, and a mock-safe worker can be evaluated in a guided pilot. Live router/RADIUS mutation remains gated; automated suspension and restoration are not a shipped promise.
Open pageSolutionsCustomer Self-Service Foundations — Guided pilot
Guided pilot: Field-job lifecycle, serialized stock, basic tickets and subscriber portal flows have narrow synthetic-data proof and remain guided pilots. Physical installs and invite email delivery are unproven. The technician PWA, dispatch board, dedicated stock workspace and IPAM remain roadmap.
Open page